Should the fire industry be regulated like the gas industry? A case for mandatory third-party certification.
For decades, those of us working within the fire safety profession have campaigned for higher standards and stronger safeguards. The systems we design, install, commission and maintain are life-critical. A single failing can put lives, property and entire communities at risk.
Despite this, the fire protection industry remains largely unregulated. Unlike the gas sector, where every engineer must be registered and products can only be installed by those holding Gas Safe certification, fire protection continues to operate under a voluntary accreditation model. Anyone can, in principle, purchase life safety equipment and attempt an installation.
This paper sets out the case for change. Drawing on lessons from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry, industry practice, and parallels with the gas sector, it argues that mandatory third-party certification and controlled product access are essential if we are serious about safeguarding lives and restoring confidence in our industry.
Current state of the fire industry
The UK fire sector is supported by respected schemes such as BAFE SP203-1 and LPS1014, and organisations like the FIA and UKAS-accredited certification bodies have worked tirelessly to raise standards. Many responsible companies have embraced these frameworks. But participation remains voluntary.
The result is a patchwork industry: some firms operate to world-class standards, while others cut corners, unchecked. The absence of universal regulation means building owners and occupants cannot be certain that systems protecting them are designed or maintained by competent professionals.
The Grenfell Inquiry underlined this shortfall. It revealed serious competency gaps in the design, installation and maintenance of fire protection measures—ranging from detection and alarm systems through to passive fire barriers. Critically, it also highlighted the lack of clear oversight and accountability.
Learning from the gas industry
The contrast with the gas sector could not be clearer. Since the introduction of the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations, every engineer working with gas must be registered. Product access is tightly controlled: only certified professionals can procure and install key components.
This framework ensures competence, provides a clear line of accountability, and—crucially—protects the public. It is widely accepted, and far from stifling the industry, it has strengthened professionalism and consumer trust.
There is no credible reason why the fire sector, where the consequences of failure are equally fatal, should not operate under a comparable system.
The case for mandatory certification and controlled product access in the fire industry
1. Safety and compliance
Fire protection systems are no less life-critical than gas installations. A poorly designed alarm or disabled evacuation system is as dangerous as an unserviced boiler. Universal certification would ensure only competent professionals are entrusted with these systems.
2. Consistency across the sector
At present, qualifications and standards vary widely. Mandatory third-party certification would create a level baseline, raising the overall quality of service and removing uncertainty for clients.
3. Accountability and restricted product access
Clear responsibility encourages best practice. If certification were compulsory and product access restricted to accredited professionals, accountability would be unambiguous and risks significantly reduced.
4. Reducing risks for building owners and occupants
Property managers and residents deserve certainty that their safety systems are compliant. A regulatory framework would provide this assurance, addressing one of the most damning failures highlighted by Grenfell.
5. Improving industry reputation and trust
Gas Safe registration has become a mark of competence. A similar mechanism in fire protection would raise public confidence, enhance professional standing, and deter rogue operators.
Why hasn’t the fire industry adopted a gas-style certification and product access model?
The barriers are familiar. The sector is fragmented, spanning consultants, contractors, maintainers, and manufacturers. Voluntary schemes exist, and government has so far resisted legislating for mandatory regulation. Some argue that costs and entry requirements would disadvantage smaller firms.
However, the experience of the gas industry shows these concerns are overstated. Universal regulation can be achieved without undermining competition. On the contrary, it creates a fairer market, where all operate to the same minimum standards.
A path forward: what would a fire industry certification and product access model look like?
A Gas Safe-style framework for fire protection could include:
- Mandatory Registration with a recognised, UKAS-accredited body such as BAFE.
- Restricted Product Access, ensuring only certified professionals can purchase and install fire safety equipment.
- Ongoing Competency Assessments, ensuring individuals remain current with legislation, British Standards (e.g. BS 5839-1), and best practice.
- Clear Accountability, with named responsible persons for each system installed or maintained.
- Enforcement Through Legislation, to ensure consistency and give legal weight to certification.
Looking for a fire safety partner?
We exist to protect people and places with precision. Whether your project is at the design, build or protect stage, get in touch to find out how we can work together.
info@onpointassociates.co.uk
020 8698 6295
